Performances & Results

Live show details

Week 1 (11 October 2008)

Theme: Number 1 songs in either the UK or US charts
Celebrity guest: Leon Jackson
Song performed by celebrity guest: "Don't Call This Love"

Order Artist Mentor Song (original artists) Results
1 Girlband Walsh "Venus" (The Shocking Blue) Bottom two
2 Austin Drage Cowell "Every Breath You Take" (The Police) Safe
3 Daniel Evans Minogue "I Want To Know What Love Is" (Foreigner) Safe
4 Alexandra Burke Cole "I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me)" (Whitney Houston) Safe
5 JLS Walsh "I'll Make Love To You" (Boyz II Men) Safe
6 Scott Bruton Cowell "Yeh Yeh" (Georgie Fame) Safe
7 Rachel Hylton Minogue "With Every Heartbeat" (Robyn feat. Kleerup) Safe
8 Diana Vickers Cole "With or Without You" (U2) Safe
9 Bad Lashes Walsh "It Must Have Been Love" (Roxette) Bottom two
10 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "Imagine" (John Lennon) Safe
11 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "Take My Breath Away" (Berlin) Safe
12 Laura White Cole "Fallin'" (Alicia Keys) Safe
Bottom two details
1 Girlband Walsh "That's What Friends Are For" (Rod Stewart) Safe
2 Bad Lashes Walsh "Wonderwall" (Oasis) Eliminated
Judges' votes to eliminate
bullet Cowell: Bad Lashes – Described both acts as "shocking".
bullet Cole: Girlband – Had no standout comment on either act.
bullet Minogue: Girlband – Had no standout comment on either act.
bullet Walsh: Bad Lashes – Based on the fact that he couldn't pick between two of his own acts, he chose Bad Lashes to take it to a deadlock.
Notes
bulletAs both acts received two votes from the judges, the result went to deadlock and was referred to the public vote. The act that received the fewest public votes was Bad Lashes who were duly eliminated from the show.

 

Week 2 (18 October 2008)

Theme: Songs by Michael Jackson or The Jackson 5
Celebrity guest: Girls Aloud
Song performed by celebrity guest: "The Promise"

Order Artist Mentor Michael Jackson song Results
1 Alexandra Burke Cole "I'll Be There" Safe
2 Scott Bruton Cowell "She's out of My Life" Safe
3 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "I Just Can't Stop Loving You" Bottom two
4 Girlband Walsh "Heal the World" Bottom two
5 Laura White Cole "You Are Not Alone" Safe
6 Austin Drage Cowell "Billie Jean" Safe
7 Daniel Evans Minogue "One Day in Your Life" Safe
8 JLS Walsh "The Way You Make Me Feel" Safe
9 Diana Vickers Cole "Man in the Mirror" Safe
10 Rachel Hylton Minogue "Dirty Diana" Safe
11 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "Ben" Safe
Bottom two details
1 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "Purple Rain" (Prince) Safe
2 Girlband Walsh "I Don't Wanna Miss A Thing" (Aerosmith) Eliminated
Judges' votes to eliminate
bullet Walsh: Ruth Lorenzo – Backing his own act, Girlband.
bullet Minogue: Girlband – Backing her own act, Ruth Lorenzo.
bullet Cole: Girlband – Stating that Ruth had nailed her performance of Purple Rain.
bullet Cowell: Ruth Lorenzo – Wanting it taken to deadlock.
Notes
bulletThe result again went to deadlock and Girlband were eliminated having received the fewest public votes. During the show, a mistake was made in one of the overlays and Ruth's number was briefly displayed incorrectly, meaning any calls to that number would not have registered a vote. After the show, viewers complained that they had dialled this incorrect number and could not get through to vote for Ruth, but ITV insisted the issue should not have made any difference to the overall result.[21]

 

Week 3 (25 October 2008)

Theme: Big Band
Celebrity guest: None
Song performed by celebrity guest: No celebrity guest; in the results show the finalists instead performed a cover version of the Mariah Carey song "Hero" on behalf of the Help for Heroes charity. This song was released on Sunday 26 as a download and Monday 27 physically.

Order Artist Mentor Song (original artists) Results
1 Scott Bruton Cowell "That's Life" (Frank Sinatra) Bottom two
2 Daniel Evans Minogue "The Lady Is A Tramp" (Frank Sinatra) Bottom two
3 Laura White Cole "God Bless the Child" (Billie Holiday) Safe
4 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "L-O-V-E" (Nat King Cole) Safe
5 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "Summertime" (Ella Fitzgerald) Safe
6 Alexandra Burke Cole "Candyman" (Christina Aguilera) Safe
7 Austin Drage Cowell "Mack The Knife" (Louis Armstrong) Safe
8 JLS Walsh "Ain't That A Kick In The Head?" (Dean Martin) Safe
9 Diana Vickers Cole "Smile" (Charlie Chaplin) Safe
10 Rachel Hylton Minogue "Feeling Good" (Gilbert Price) Safe
Bottom two details
1 Scott Bruton Cowell "I Can't Make You Love Me" (Bonnie Raitt) Eliminated
2 Daniel Evans Minogue "To Where You Are" (Josh Groban) Safe
Judges' votes to eliminate
bullet Cowell: Daniel Evans – Backing his own act, Scott Bruton.
bullet Cole: Scott Bruton – Commented that Scott lacked passion.
bullet Minogue: Scott Bruton – Backing her own act, Daniel Evans.
bullet Walsh: Scott Bruton – Commented that Daniel "sang every word like he meant it".

 

Week 4 (1 November 2008)

Theme: Disco[22]
Celebrity guest: Will Young[23]
Song performed by celebrity guest: "Grace"

Order Artist Mentor Song (original artists) Results
1 Rachel Hylton Minogue "Lost In Music" (Sister Sledge) Bottom two
2 Austin Drage Cowell "Wishing on a Star" (Rose Royce) Bottom two
3 Diana Vickers Cole "Call Me" (Blondie) Safe
4 Daniel Evans Minogue "Don't Leave Me This Way" (Harold Melvin & The Blue Notes) Safe
5 Laura White Cole "Somebody Else’s Guy" (Jocelyn Brown) Safe
6 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "Could It Be Magic" (Barry Manilow) Safe
7 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "No More Tears (Enough Is Enough)" (Donna Summer & Barbra Streisand) Safe
8 Alexandra Burke Cole "On The Radio" (Donna Summer) Safe
9 JLS Walsh Medley of "Working My Way Back To You"/"Forgive Me Girl" (Frankie Valli & The Four Seasons/The Spinners) Safe
Bottom two details
1 Rachel Hylton Minogue "No More Drama" (Mary J. Blige) Safe
2 Austin Drage Cowell "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow" (The Shirelles) Eliminated
Judges' votes to eliminate
bullet Cowell: Rachel Hylton – Backing his own act, Austin Drage.
bullet Cole: Austin Drage – Stated she was prepared to give Rachel a "moment to shine".
bullet Minogue: Austin Drage – Backing her own act, Rachel Hylton.
bullet Walsh: Austin Drage – Said Rachel had "raw talent".

 

Week 5 (8 November 2008)

Theme: Songs by Mariah Carey[24]
Celebrity guest: Mariah Carey
Song performed by celebrity guest: "I Stay in Love"; Carey also performed a special version of "Hero" with 11 of the 12 finalists, Diana Vickers was suffering from laryngitis so couldn't attend. [25]

Order Artist Mentor Mariah Carey song Results
1 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "Anytime You Need a Friend" Safe
2 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "My All" Bottom two
3 Laura White Cole "Endless Love" Bottom two
4 Rachel Hylton Minogue "Against All Odds" Safe
5 Diana Vickers Cole N/A – see note below. Safe
6 JLS Walsh "One Sweet Day" Safe
7 Daniel Evans Minogue "Open Arms" Safe
8 Alexandra Burke Cole "Without You" Safe
Bottom two details
1 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" (Bob Dylan) Safe
2 Laura White Cole "Over the Rainbow" (Judy Garland) Eliminated
Judges' votes to eliminate
bullet Cowell: Laura White – Commenting that the girls "were not the worst singers of the night".
bullet Cole: Ruth Lorenzo – Backing her own act, Laura White.
bullet Minogue: Laura White – Backing her own act, Ruth Lorenzo.
bullet Walsh: Laura White – Commenting that Ruth Lorenzo was more of a "battler".
Notes
bullet Diana Vickers did not perform as she was suffering from laryngitis. The show's producers allowed her to go through to week six. It is the first time this has happened in the show's history. The producers of the show gave the following statement; "Diana Vickers did not perform on tonight's The X Factor on doctor's orders. Because of these exceptional circumstances producers have let her miss this week's show and she will return to the competition next week. All other artists supported this decision."[26] Vickers had been due to perform "Always Be My Baby".[27]

 

Week 6 (15 November 2008)

Theme: Best of British
Celebrity guest: Leona Lewis
Song performed by celebrity guest: "Run" [28]

Order Artist Mentor Song (original artists) Results
1 Daniel Evans Minogue "It's Not Unusual" (Tom Jones) Bottom two
2 Alexandra Burke Cole "You Are So Beautiful" (Billy Preston) Safe
3 JLS Walsh Medley of "I Want to Hold Your Hand" (The Beatles)/"Twist and Shout" (The Isley Brothers)/"Hey Jude" (The Beatles) Safe
4 Rachel Hylton Minogue "You Know I'm No Good" (Amy Winehouse) Bottom two
5 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "One More Try" (George Michael) Safe
6 Diana Vickers Cole "Yellow" (Coldplay) Safe
7 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "Angels" (Robbie Williams) Safe
Bottom two details
1 Daniel Evans Minogue "Bridge Over Troubled Water" (Simon & Garfunkel) Eliminated
2 Rachel Hylton Minogue "One" (U2) Safe
Judges' votes to eliminate
bullet Walsh: Daniel Evans – Had no standout comment on either performance, though had consistently criticised Daniel throughout the competition.
bullet Cole: Daniel Evans – Had no standout comment on either act.
bullet Cowell: Daniel Evans – Commented that Rachel "threw it away" with her performance and that he would have liked to see her perform with a bit more passion, but said, "This may come as a surprise, but the act I'm going to send home is Daniel."
bullet Minogue: Did not vote as there was already a majority. When asked by Dermot O'Leary which way she would have voted had her vote been required, she said she would have been unable to decide and would have sent it to deadlock.

Notes

bulletDuring the week, ITV were uncertain if Diana would be able to perform due to her continued illness, and raised the question of whether she should be given another week off if she was still too sick to sing.[29] It was, however, later confirmed that she would appear.[30]
bulletJLS performed their three songs as a medley.

 

Week 7 (22 November 2008)

Theme: Songs by Take That[31]
Celebrity guests: Take That, Same Difference and Rhydian Roberts[32]
Songs performed by celebrity guests: "Greatest Day" (Take That), "We R One" (Same Difference) and "The Impossible Dream" (Rhydian Roberts)

Order Artist Mentor Take That song Results
1 Alexandra Burke Cole "Relight My Fire" Safe
2 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "Love Ain't Here Anymore" Safe
3 JLS Walsh "A Million Love Songs" Bottom two
4 Rachel Hylton Minogue "Rule the World" Bottom two
5 Diana Vickers Cole "Patience" Safe
6 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "Never Forget" Safe
Bottom two details
1 JLS Walsh "Stand by Me"/"Beautiful Girls" (Ben E. King/Sean Kingston) Safe
2 Rachel Hylton Minogue "And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going" (Jennifer Holliday) Eliminated

Judges' votes to eliminate:

bullet Walsh: Rachel Hylton – Backing his own act, JLS.
bullet Minogue: JLS – Backing her own act, Rachel Hylton.
bullet Cole: Rachel Hylton – Stated that it had been the best Rachel had sung since the auditions, but said JLS would go further in the competition than Rachel.
bullet Cowell: Rachel Hylton – Stated that this was the third time Rachel was in the bottom two, and that JLS shouldn't have been in the bottom two.

Notes

bulletJLS had previously been rehearsing to sing "Rule the World", with the approval of their mentor, Louis Walsh. Contrary to this, as Dannii Minogue had higher priority in the judges' song-selection rota, she selected the song for her artist Rachel Hylton to sing. This led to an on-screen argument between Minogue and Walsh.[33]

 

Week 8 (29 November 2008)

Theme: Songs by Britney Spears and American classics
Celebrity guest: Britney Spears and Miley Cyrus[34]
Song performed by celebrity guests: "Womanizer" (Britney Spears), "7 Things" (Miley Cyrus) [35]

Order Artist Mentor First song (Britney Spears song) Order Artist Second song (original artists) Results
1 Ruth Lorenzo Minogue "I Love Rock 'n Roll" 6 Ruth Lorenzo "Always" (Bon Jovi) Eliminated
2 JLS Walsh "...Baby One More Time" 7 JLS "You Light Up My Life" (Debby Boone) Safe
3 Alexandra Burke Cole "Toxic" 8 Alexandra Burke "Listen" (Beyonc้) Safe
4 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "Sometimes" 9 Eoghan Quigg "We're All In This Together" (High School Musical) Safe
5 Diana Vickers Cole "I'm Not A Girl, Not Yet A Woman" 10 Diana Vickers "Everybody Hurts" (R.E.M.) Safe

Notes:

bulletThis week, there was no bottom two; the act that received the fewest public votes was automatically eliminated. Each act also performed twice, with voting open after all acts performed once.
bulletDespite a live performance by Britney Spears, the Miley Cyrus performance was recorded before the main live broadcast due to her tight schedule.[citation needed]
bulletBritney Spears' performance was lip-synced, performed to a backing track. [36]

 

Week 9 (Semi-final, 6 December 2008)

Theme: Judges' and contestants' choice – acts will sing two songs: one chosen by their mentor and one that they have chosen themselves.[37]
Celebrity guest: Il Divo [38]
Song performed by celebrity guest: "Amazing Grace"

Order Artist Mentor First song - mentor's choice (original artists) Order Artist Second song - contestant's choice (original artists) Results
1 Eoghan Quigg Cowell "Year 3000" (Busted) 5 Eoghan Quigg "Does Your Mother Know?" (ABBA) Safe
2 Diana Vickers Cole "Girlfriend" (Avril Lavigne) 6 Diana Vickers "White Flag" (Dido) Eliminated
3 Alexandra Burke Cole "Don't Stop the Music" (Rihanna) 7 Alexandra Burke "Un-Break My Heart" (Toni Braxton) Safe
4 JLS Walsh "Umbrella" (Rihanna) 8 JLS "I'm Already There" (Lonestar) Safe